someone offered me this trade

[gatorbait08]

He offered me, favre, mike williams and tony gonzales. For matt schaub and eddie royal. What you think?

 

[JakeT.]

I'd say it depends on what you have at all your spots. Tough to say without that info.

 

[gatorbait08]

Qb matt schaub, kyle orton, vince young. R b ray rice, ryan torain, greene, thomas jones. W r D. Jackson, malcolm floyd, brandon lloyd, santonio holmes, eddie royal. TE A. Hernandez, k matt bryant. Def pitt. Sorry if this is hard to read. I'm on my phone

 

[JakeT.]

Royal > Williams
Schaub > Favre

TE upgrade would be nice but you don't need it that bad.

 

[HacheMan]

Although Favre is in line to start putting up big numbers again with the addition of Randy Moss and Sidney Rice back soon, I don't think the swap is worth losing Eddie Royal Over.

Looks like you need to counter-offer to him or someone else Schaub or Orton with Royal, Jackson, or Floyd to get a 2nd quality RB to go along with Rice....